Sign Up

Continue with Google
or use


Have an account? Sign In Now

Sign In

Continue with Google
or use

Forgot Password?

Don't have account, Sign Up Here

Forgot Password

Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.

Have an account? Sign In Now

You must login to ask question.

Continue with Google
or use

Forgot Password?

Need An Account, Sign Up Here

You must login to ask question.

Continue with Google
or use

Forgot Password?

Need An Account, Sign Up Here
Taxchopal Logo Taxchopal Logo
Sign InSign Up

Taxchopal

Taxchopal Navigation

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Services
  • Blog
Search
Ask A Question

Mobile menu

Close
Ask a Question
  • Home
  • Services
  • Blog
  • Income Tax
  • GST
  • Accountancy
  • Finance
  • Corporate Laws
  • Others
  • Users
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Services
  • Blog

CA Vishnu Ram

Enlightened
Ask CA Vishnu Ram
1Follower
189Questions
Home/ CA Vishnu Ram/Questions
  • About
  • Questions
  • Polls
  • Answers
  • Best Answers
  • Groups

Taxchopal Latest Questions

CA Vishnu Ram
CA Vishnu RamEnlightened
Asked: February 12, 2022In: Income Tax

What is the limit of remuneration of partner as per Income Tax act?

  1. Advocate Dr Amit Dua Explainer
    Added an answer on February 18, 2022 at 12:50 pm

    a) Interest payable to partners shall be in accordance with the terms of the partnership deed, however, it shall not exceed 12% per annum. b) Remuneration payable to partners shall be in accordance with the terms of the partnership deed, however, it shall not exceed the following limit: On first Rs.Read more

    • a) Interest payable to partners shall be in accordance with the terms of the partnership deed, however, it shall not exceed 12% per annum.
    • b) Remuneration payable to partners shall be in accordance with the terms of the partnership deed, however, it shall not exceed the following limit:
      • On first Rs. 3 Lakhs of book profit or in case of loss – Rs. 1,50,000 or 90% of book profit, whichever is more;
      • On the balance of the book profit – 60% of book profit.
    See less
    • 1
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
  • 1 1 Answer
  • 34 Views
  • 0 Votes
Answer
CA Vishnu Ram
CA Vishnu RamEnlightened
Asked: February 12, 2022In: Income Tax

What is the limit of remuneration of partner as per Income Tax act?

  1. CA Manish Kumar Gupta Enlightened
    Added an answer on February 18, 2022 at 5:19 pm

    Section 40b describes the maximum amount of remuneration and interest on capital payable to a partner under Income Tax Act. Excess to this amount will not be allowed as a deduction from the income of the firm. Remuneration in a partnership firm is allowed as a deduction if the following conditions aRead more

    Section 40b describes the maximum amount of remuneration and interest on capital payable to a partner under Income Tax Act. Excess to this amount will not be allowed as a deduction from the income of the firm.

    Remuneration in a partnership firm is allowed as a deduction if the following conditions are satisfied:

    1. Remuneration is allowed only to working partners.
    2. Remuneration must be authorized by the partnership deed and according to the terms of the partnership deed.
    3. Also, the amount of salary or manner of its computation is to be mentioned in the deed. If there is not any such provision in deed then no deduction is allowed. If it is mentioned in the deed that salary is allowed to partners as per the maximum limit defined under this section then this condition is satisfied.
    4. It should be related to the period of the partnership deed.
    5. It is not allowed if the income of the partner ship firm is calculated on the basis of section 44AD or section 44ADA (Presumptive Income).
    6. Remuneration should be within the permissible limits as mentioned below. This limit is for the total salary to all partners and not per partner.
    Book Profit Amount deductible as remuneration under section 40(b)
    If book profit is negative Rs. 1,50,000
    If book profit is positive-   On first Rs. 3 lakh of book profit On the balance of book profit Rs. 1,50,000 or 90% of book profit whichever is more  60% of book profit

    Calculation of book profit

    Profit as per Profit & Loss a/c –                                                                                      xxx
    Add- Remuneration to partners if debited to Profit and loss a/c
    Add- Brought forward business loss, deduction under section 80C
    to 80U if debited to profit and loss a/c
    Less – Income under house property, capital gain, other
    sources if credited to profit and loss a/c
    Book Profits                                                                                                                    xxx

    Such Remuneration will be taxable in the hands of receiving partner as “Income from Business or Profession” but If such remuneration is not allowed as an expense in hands of the partnership firm then it will not be taxable in the hands of partners.

    See less
    • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
  • 1 1 Answer
  • 32 Views
  • 0 Votes
Answer
CA Vishnu Ram
CA Vishnu RamEnlightened
Asked: February 12, 2022In: Income Tax

When salary to a partner is not allowed as deduction under the Income Tax Act?

  1. CA Manish Kumar Gupta Enlightened
    Added an answer on April 9, 2025 at 2:29 pm

    Section 40(b) specifies that the remuneration to a partner may be allowed as a deduction if: It is provided for in the partnership deed or fixed as per a prior arrangement. It is calculated on a predetermined basis irrespective of the profits or turnover of the firm. The payment is made in advance oRead more

    Section 40(b) specifies that the remuneration to a partner may be allowed as a deduction if:

    • It is provided for in the partnership deed or fixed as per a prior arrangement.

    • It is calculated on a predetermined basis irrespective of the profits or turnover of the firm.

    • The payment is made in advance or sanctioned for the relevant assessment year.

    When Is Salary to a Partner Not Allowed?

    The salary (or any form of remuneration) to a partner will be disallowed as a deduction under the following circumstances:

      1. Not Provided for in the Partnership Deed:
        If the partnership deed does not expressly authorize or specify the payment of salary to the partner, any such payment made by the firm is not in line with the agreed terms and, therefore, will not be treated as an allowable deduction.

      2. Excessive or Arbitrary Payment:
        Even if a salary is mentioned in the partnership deed, if the firm pays an amount that exceeds the rate or limits fixed by the deed (or as per the conditions prescribed under Section 40(b)), the excess portion of the salary will be disallowed. The Act expects the remuneration to be predetermined and not subject to arbitrary increases.

      3. Non-Compliance with the Prescribed Formula:
        The Act mandates that the salary should be computed on a fixed formula (or rate) as stipulated in the deed, without being linked to the fluctuating profits of the firm. If the payment deviates from this method – for example, if it is linked directly to profits, thereby possibly distorting the firm’s taxable income – the deduction may be disallowed to the extent of the deviation.

    See less
    • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
  • 1 1 Answer
  • 31 Views
  • 0 Votes
Answer
CA Vishnu Ram
CA Vishnu RamEnlightened
Asked: February 12, 2022In: Income Tax

What is the limit of remuneration of partner as per Income Tax act?

  1. CA Vishnu Ram Enlightened
    Added an answer on March 12, 2025 at 3:13 pm

    The remuneration (salary, bonus, commission, etc.) paid to partners in a partnership firm is allowed as a deduction under Section 40(b) of the Income Tax Act, but only within prescribed limits based on the book profit of the firm. Maximum Allowable Remuneration (as per Section 40(b)) ✅ If Book ProfiRead more

    The remuneration (salary, bonus, commission, etc.) paid to partners in a partnership firm is allowed as a deduction under Section 40(b) of the Income Tax Act, but only within prescribed limits based on the book profit of the firm.

    Maximum Allowable Remuneration (as per Section 40(b))

    ✅ If Book Profit is ₹3 lakh or less → 90% of book profit or ₹1.5 lakh (whichever is higher)

    ✅ If Book Profit is above ₹3 lakh → 60% of book profit

    🔹 Important Conditions:

    • The remuneration must be paid only to working partners.
    • It must be authorized in the partnership deed.
    • The remuneration should be within the prescribed limit; any excess is disallowed as an expense.

    📌 Example Calculation:

    • If a firm’s book profit is ₹2 lakh, the max allowable partner remuneration = ₹1.5 lakh (since it’s higher than 90% of ₹2 lakh).
    • If a firm’s book profit is ₹10 lakh, the max allowable remuneration = (90% of ₹3 lakh) + (60% of ₹7 lakh) = ₹2.7 lakh + ₹4.2 lakh = ₹6.9 lakh.

    ✅ Conclusion:
    Partner remuneration is deductible only if it follows Section 40(b) rules. If it exceeds limits, the extra amount is disallowed for tax purposes.

    See less
    • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
  • 1 1 Answer
  • 23 Views
  • 0 Votes
Answer
CA Vishnu Ram
CA Vishnu RamEnlightened
Asked: February 12, 2022In: Income Tax

What are the conditions of section 40b for getting deduction of remuneration in a firm?

  1. CA Vishnu Ram Enlightened
    Added an answer on March 12, 2025 at 3:13 pm

    Under Section 40(b) of the Income Tax Act, a partnership firm can claim a deduction for remuneration paid to partners, but it must satisfy the following conditions: 1️⃣ Remuneration Must Be Paid to "Working Partners" Only Only working partners (actively engaged in business) are eligible for remuneraRead more

    Under Section 40(b) of the Income Tax Act, a partnership firm can claim a deduction for remuneration paid to partners, but it must satisfy the following conditions:

    1️⃣ Remuneration Must Be Paid to “Working Partners” Only

    • Only working partners (actively engaged in business) are eligible for remuneration.
    • Sleeping (non-working) partners are not entitled to remuneration deduction.

    2️⃣ Must Be Authorized by the Partnership Deed

    • The partnership deed must specify the remuneration amount or the calculation method.
    • If the deed is silent on remuneration, the firm cannot claim a deduction.

    3️⃣ Payment Should Be Within the Prescribed Limits

    • Remuneration should not exceed the maximum limits prescribed under Section 40(b):
      ✅ Book profit ≤ ₹3 lakh → 90% of book profit or ₹1.5 lakh (whichever is higher)
      ✅ Book profit > ₹3 lakh → 60% of book profit

    4️⃣ Remuneration Must Be Paid to an Individual Partner

    • If a partner is a company or LLP, remuneration paid to them is not deductible.

    5️⃣ The Partnership Deed Must Be in Effect

    • The partnership deed should be signed and in force before the end of the financial year.
    • If the deed is amended to change remuneration, the amendment must apply prospectively, not retrospectively.

    6️⃣ Firm Must Be Assessed as a Partnership Firm

    • The firm must be assessed as a partnership firm under the Income Tax Act.
    • Firms taxed under presumptive taxation schemes (Section 44AD/44ADA) cannot claim this deduction.

    ✅ Conclusion:
    To claim a deduction for partner remuneration, ensure it is paid to a working partner, authorized in the deed, within Section 40(b) limits, and in a firm recognized as a partnership under the Income Tax Act.

    See less
    • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
  • 1 1 Answer
  • 23 Views
  • 0 Votes
Answer
CA Vishnu Ram
CA Vishnu RamEnlightened
Asked: February 12, 2022In: Income Tax

What are the conditions of section 40b for getting deduction of remuneration in a firm?

  1. Advocate Dr Amit Dua Explainer
    Added an answer on February 25, 2022 at 5:55 pm

    Section 40b determines the maximum amount of remuneration and interest on capital payable to a partner under Income Tax Act. The amount over the specified limit is not allowed as a deduction to a partnership firm. Remuneration To Partners Remuneration includes salary, bonus, commission .RemunerationRead more

    Section 40b determines the maximum amount of remuneration and interest on capital payable to a partner under Income Tax Act. The amount over the specified limit is not allowed as a deduction to a partnership firm.

    Remuneration To Partners

    Remuneration includes salary, bonus, commission .Remuneration in partnership firm is allowed as a deduction if following conditions are satisfied

    1. Remuneration is allowed only to working partners.
    2. Remuneration must be authorised by partnership deed and according to the terms of partnership deed. Also the amount of salary or manner of its computation is to be mentioned in the deed. If there is not any such provision in deed then no deduction is allowed. Normally people mentions in deed that salary is allowed to partners as per maximum limit defined under this section. This clause satisfies the condition for quantum of deduction.
    3. It should be related to the period of the partnership deed. If there is another partnership deed for another period then such deed’s provisions will be considered for that period.
    4. It is not allowed if tax is paid on presumptive basis under section 44AD or section 44ADA.
    5. Remuneration should be within the permissible limits as mentioned below. Please note that this limit is for total salary to all partners and not per partner.
    See less
    • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
  • 1 1 Answer
  • 32 Views
  • 0 Votes
Answer
CA Vishnu Ram
CA Vishnu RamEnlightened
Asked: February 12, 2022In: Income Tax

What are the conditions of section 40b for getting deduction of remuneration in a firm?

  1. Advocate Dr Amit Dua Explainer
    Added an answer on February 19, 2022 at 11:22 am

    Section 40b determines the maximum amount of remuneration and interest on capital payable to a partner under Income Tax Act. The amount over the specified limit is not allowed as a deduction to a partnership firm. Remuneration To Partners Remuneration includes salary, bonus, commission .RemunerationRead more

    Section 40b determines the maximum amount of remuneration and interest on capital payable to a partner under Income Tax Act. The amount over the specified limit is not allowed as a deduction to a partnership firm.

    Remuneration To Partners

    Remuneration includes salary, bonus, commission .Remuneration in partnership firm is allowed as a deduction if following conditions are satisfied

    1. Remuneration is allowed only to working partners.
    2. Remuneration must be authorised by partnership deed and according to the terms of partnership deed. Also the amount of salary or manner of its computation is to be mentioned in the deed. If there is not any such provision in deed then no deduction is allowed. Normally people mentions in deed that salary is allowed to partners as per maximum limit defined under this section. This clause satisfies the condition for quantum of deduction.
    3. It should be related to the period of the partnership deed. If there is another partnership deed for another period then such deed’s provisions will be considered for that period.
    4. It is not allowed if tax is paid on presumptive basis under section 44AD or section 44ADA.
    5. Remuneration should be within the permissible limits as mentioned below. Please note that this limit is for total salary to all partners and not per partner.
    Book Profit Amount deductible as remuneration under section 40(b)
    If book profit is negative Rs. 1,50,000
    If book profit is positive-   On first Rs. 3 lakh of book profit On the balance of book profit Rs. 1,50,000 or 90% of book profit whichever is more   60% of book profit

    Calculation of book profit

    Profit as per Profit & Loss a/c –                                                                                      xxx
    Add- Remuneration to partners if debited to Profit and loss a/c
    Add- Brought forward business loss, deduction under section 80C
    to 80U if debited to profit and loss a/c
    Less – Income under house property, capital gain, other
    sources if credited to profit and loss a/c
    Book Profits                                                                                                                    xxx

    Example-

    Book profit = Rs. 9 Lakhs
    Maximum allowed salary = 3,00,000*90% + 6,00,000*60% = Rs. 6.3 lakhs

    Remuneration which is allowed as expenses in the hands of partnership firm will be taxable in the hands of receiving partner as “Income from Business or Profession”.

    If such remuneration is not allowed as expense in hands of partnership firm then it will not be taxable in the hands of partners.

    See less
    • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
  • 1 1 Answer
  • 31 Views
  • 0 Votes
Answer
CA Vishnu Ram
CA Vishnu RamEnlightened
Asked: February 12, 2022In: Income Tax

What are the conditions of section 184 for claiming deduction of remuneration and interest by a firm?

  1. CA Vishnu Ram Enlightened
    Added an answer on March 13, 2025 at 1:05 pm

    Under Section 184 of the Income Tax Act, a partnership firm can claim deduction for remuneration and interest paid to partners, but it must fulfill the following conditions: Conditions for Claiming Deduction under Section 184 1️⃣ The Firm Must Be a Valid Partnership Firm The firm must be a genuine pRead more

    Under Section 184 of the Income Tax Act, a partnership firm can claim deduction for remuneration and interest paid to partners, but it must fulfill the following conditions:

    Conditions for Claiming Deduction under Section 184

    1️⃣ The Firm Must Be a Valid Partnership Firm

    • The firm must be a genuine partnership as per the Indian Partnership Act, 1932.
    • The firm should be assessed as a partnership firm under the Income Tax Act.

    2️⃣ Partnership Deed Must Be in Writing

    • A written partnership deed must exist.
    • It should clearly mention the profit-sharing ratio of partners.
    • It must be signed by all partners.

    3️⃣ Remuneration & Interest Must Be Authorized in the Partnership Deed

    • Partner’s remuneration (salary, bonus, commission, etc.) and interest on capital must be mentioned in the partnership deed.
    • If the deed does not specify these payments, the firm cannot claim deductions.

    4️⃣ Interest and Remuneration Should Be Within the Prescribed Limits

    • Interest on partner’s capital must not exceed 12% per annum (as per Section 40(b)).
    • Remuneration paid to partners should not exceed the limits prescribed under Section 40(b) (based on book profit).

    5️⃣ The Firm Must File a Valid Income Tax Return

    • The firm must file its income tax return on time.
    • Delay in filing may lead to disallowance of these deductions.

    6️⃣ Changes in the Partnership Deed Must Be Reported

    • If there is any change in the partnership deed, the firm must submit a certified copy to the Income Tax Department.

    ✅ Conclusion:
    To claim deductions for remuneration and interest paid to partners, ensure that:
    ✔️ A valid partnership deed exists and is filed with the Income Tax Department.
    ✔️ Interest and remuneration are within the prescribed limits of Section 40(b).
    ✔️ The firm is assessed as a partnership firm and files its return on time.

    See less
    • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
  • 1 1 Answer
  • 24 Views
  • 0 Votes
Answer
CA Vishnu Ram
CA Vishnu RamEnlightened
Asked: February 11, 2022In: Income Tax

When a trader is liable to deduct TCS on sale of goods?

  1. CA Sanjiv Kumar Enlightened Chartered Accountant
    Added an answer on March 13, 2025 at 1:08 pm

    A trader is liable to deduct TCS (Tax Collected at Source) on the sale of goods under Section 206C(1H) of the Income Tax Act, subject to the following conditions: 1️⃣ Applicability of TCS on Sale of Goods (Sec 206C(1H)) ✔️ The seller must have a turnover exceeding ₹10 crore in the previous financialRead more

    A trader is liable to deduct TCS (Tax Collected at Source) on the sale of goods under Section 206C(1H) of the Income Tax Act, subject to the following conditions:

    1️⃣ Applicability of TCS on Sale of Goods (Sec 206C(1H))

    ✔️ The seller must have a turnover exceeding ₹10 crore in the previous financial year.
    ✔️ TCS applies when the buyer purchases goods worth more than ₹50 lakh in a financial year.
    ✔️ TCS is applicable only on the amount exceeding ₹50 lakh.

    2️⃣ TCS Rate on Sale of Goods

    ✔️ 0.1% of the amount exceeding ₹50 lakh (If PAN is available).
    ✔️ 1% if the buyer does not provide a PAN or Aadhaar.

    3️⃣ When to Collect & Deposit TCS?

    ✔️ TCS should be collected at the time of receipt of payment from the buyer.
    ✔️ It must be deposited with the government by the 7th of the next month.

    4️⃣ Exemptions from TCS on Sale of Goods

    ❌ TCS is NOT applicable if:

    • The buyer is the government, embassy, RBI, or public sector company.
    • The sale is already subject to TDS under any other provision.

    ✅ Example:
    If a trader has a turnover of ₹12 crore in the last financial year and sells goods worth ₹60 lakh to a customer, TCS will be applicable on ₹10 lakh (₹60 lakh – ₹50 lakh).

    TCS Calculation:
    👉 TCS @0.1% on ₹10 lakh = ₹1,000 (if PAN is available).

    See less
    • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
  • 1 1 Answer
  • 31 Views
  • 0 Votes
Answer
CA Vishnu Ram
CA Vishnu RamEnlightened
Asked: February 11, 2022In: Income Tax

What are the TCS rates?

  1. CA Sanjiv Kumar Enlightened Chartered Accountant
    Added an answer on March 13, 2025 at 1:09 pm

    TCS (Tax Collected at Source) Rates for FY 2024-25 The TCS rates under Section 206C of the Income Tax Act vary based on the nature of the transaction. Below is a summary of the latest applicable rates: Nature of Transaction Section TCS Rate (with PAN/Aadhaar) TCS Rate (without PAN/Aadhaar) Sale of ARead more

    TCS (Tax Collected at Source) Rates for FY 2024-25

    The TCS rates under Section 206C of the Income Tax Act vary based on the nature of the transaction. Below is a summary of the latest applicable rates:

    Nature of Transaction Section TCS Rate (with PAN/Aadhaar) TCS Rate (without PAN/Aadhaar)
    Sale of Alcoholic Liquor, Tendu Leaves, Timber, Forest Produce 206C(1) 1% – 5% (varies) 5%
    Sale of Scrap 206C(1) 1% 5%
    Sale of Minerals (Coal, Lignite, Iron Ore) 206C(1) 1% 5%
    Sale of Motor Vehicle (above ₹10 lakh) 206C(1F) 1% 5%
    Sale of Goods (if turnover > ₹10 Cr & buyer purchases > ₹50 lakh in a year) 206C(1H) 0.1% (on excess amount) 1%
    Foreign Remittance under LRS (except for education/medical purposes) 206C(1G) 20% 20%
    Foreign Tour Package Purchase 206C(1G) 5% 10%
    Education Loan financed by a financial institution 206C(1G) 0.5% 5%
    Sale of Overseas Tour Program Package 206C(1G) 5% 10%
    TCS on E-commerce Operator (Payments to Seller) 206C(1H) 1% 5%

    Important Points:

    ✔ PAN/Aadhaar is mandatory for lower TCS rates.
    ✔ TCS must be collected at the time of receiving payment from the buyer.
    ✔ TCS must be deposited by the 7th of the next month.
    ✔ The buyer can claim TCS credit while filing their Income Tax Return.

    See less
    • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
  • 1 1 Answer
  • 38 Views
  • 0 Votes
Answer
Load More Questions

Sidebar

Ask A Question

Stats

  • Questions 796
  • Answers 504
  • Posts 11
  • Users 202
  • Popular
  • Answers
  • Ankit

    Is interest paid on home loan included in the cost ...

    • 3 Answers
  • admin

    What are the different types of accounting?

    • 1 Answer
  • admin

    What income do I have to pay taxes on?

    • 2 Answers
  • CA Sanjiv Kumar
    CA Sanjiv Kumar added an answer Hi Ankit, Buying a property from an NRI will require… July 15, 2025 at 11:43 am
  • CA Manish Kumar Gupta
    CA Manish Kumar Gupta added an answer No, Notarization or Registration of a Will is Not Mandatory… June 20, 2025 at 2:32 pm
  • CA Manish Kumar Gupta
    CA Manish Kumar Gupta added an answer Hi You can mention ancestral property in your Will only… June 20, 2025 at 2:30 pm

Top Members

CA Sanjiv Kumar

CA Sanjiv Kumar

  • 271 Questions
  • 3k Points
Enlightened
CA Vishnu Ram

CA Vishnu Ram

  • 189 Questions
  • 3k Points
Enlightened
CA Manish Kumar Gupta

CA Manish Kumar Gupta

  • 4 Questions
  • 1k Points
Enlightened

Trending Tags

interest paid on personal loan QRMP Scheme under GST RBI guidelines on current account

Explore

  • Home
  • Services
  • Blog
  • Income Tax
  • GST
  • Accountancy
  • Finance
  • Corporate Laws
  • Others
  • Users

Footer

  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

© 2021 Taxchopal. All Rights Reserved.