Home/Income Tax

Taxchopal Latest Questions

CA Vishnu Ram
Enlightened
Asked: In:

  1. CA Sanjiv Kumar Enlightened Chartered Accountant

    Step-by-Step Computation Let’s assume you sell a capital asset (other than a residential house) and want to compute the exemption on the long-term capital gain under Section 54F. Step 1: Compute the Long-Term Capital Gain (LTCG) LTCG = Sale Consideration – (Indexed Cost of Acquisition + Direct ExpenRead more

    Step-by-Step Computation

    Let’s assume you sell a capital asset (other than a residential house) and want to compute the exemption on the long-term capital gain under Section 54F.

    Step 1: Compute the Long-Term Capital Gain (LTCG)

    • LTCG = Sale Consideration – (Indexed Cost of Acquisition + Direct Expenses)

      • (Remember, for long-term assets, indexation is allowed under Section 55(2).)

    Step 2: Determine the Net Sale Consideration

    • This is the total amount received from the sale after subtracting any expenses directly attributable to the sale (such as brokerage).

    Step 3: Invest the Net Sale Consideration

    • Ensure that the entire net sale consideration is reinvested in a residential house property as per the prescribed timeline.

    Step 4: Calculate the Exemption

    • Exemption Amount = (Investment in Residential House × LTCG) / Net Sale Consideration

      • If the entire net sale consideration is reinvested, the exemption equals the entire LTCG.

      • If only a part is reinvested, then only the proportionate share of the gain gets exempted.

    Step 5: Tax on the Remaining Gain (if any)

    • The remaining capital gain (if any) that is not covered by the exemption is subject to tax at the applicable long-term capital gains rate (20% plus applicable surcharge and cess).

    See less
    • 0
CA Vishnu Ram
Enlightened
Asked: In:

  1. CA Sanjiv Kumar Enlightened Chartered Accountant

    Under the Income Tax Act, 1961, agricultural income is fully exempt from tax. Although the Act does not expressly provide a separate exemption for “capital gains” on agricultural land, the judicial interpretation of agricultural income has played a key role in this area. Section 10(1) of the IncomeRead more

    Under the Income Tax Act, 1961, agricultural income is fully exempt from tax. Although the Act does not expressly provide a separate exemption for “capital gains” on agricultural land, the judicial interpretation of agricultural income has played a key role in this area.

    • Section 10(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961:
      This provision exempts agricultural income from tax. “Agricultural income” is defined broadly through judicial interpretation and includes income derived from agricultural operations. In many cases, the capital gain on the sale of land that qualifies as agricultural (i.e., land used solely for agriculture and situated in rural areas as defined by state law) has been treated as agricultural income and thereby exempt from tax.

    • Criteria for Agricultural Land Exemption:
      For a land sale to be exempt:

      • Location: The land should be situated in a rural area (generally outside the limits of a municipality or a notified urban area).

      • Usage: The land must be used solely for agricultural purposes. If the land is used for non-agricultural purposes (or has been converted for commercial/industrial use), the exemption may not apply.

    Tax Treatment Based on Land Qualification

    • Qualifying as Agricultural Land:
      If the land meets the statutory and judicially interpreted criteria of being “agricultural”—mainly being located in a rural area and used exclusively for agriculture—the gain arising on its sale is considered as part of agricultural income and is therefore exempt from tax.

      For example, courts have held that if the land is used for agricultural operations and lies in a rural area (as per state definitions), then the capital gain on such sale is not chargeable to tax.

    • Non-Qualifying Agricultural Land:
      If the land does not meet the definition of agricultural land (for instance, if it is located within urban limits or has been converted to non-agricultural use), then the gain from its sale is treated as a capital gain under Sections 47–49 and is taxable.

    See less
    • 0
CA Vishnu Ram
Enlightened
Asked: In:

  1. CA Sanjiv Kumar Enlightened Chartered Accountant

    How to Deposit Money in the CGAS Step A: Open a CGAS Account Designated Banks:The government has notified certain banks to operate as authorized CGAS account holders. To deposit funds, you must open a CGAS account with one of these designated banks. Documentation:You will typically need to provide:Read more

    How to Deposit Money in the CGAS

    Step A: Open a CGAS Account

    • Designated Banks:
      The government has notified certain banks to operate as authorized CGAS account holders. To deposit funds, you must open a CGAS account with one of these designated banks.

    • Documentation:
      You will typically need to provide:

      • Proof of sale of the capital asset (sale deed, transaction details)

      • PAN and identity proofs

      • A declaration regarding the purpose of deposit as per the reinvestment conditions stipulated under the applicable exemption (for example, under Section 54 or 54EC)

    Step B: Deposit the Amount

    • Timing:
      You must deposit the requisite amount in the CGAS account within the time limit specified for reinvestment (for example, within two years from the date of transfer for residential property purchase under Section 54, or within six months for Section 54EC bonds).

    • Mechanism:
      The deposit is made as you would for any regular bank account transaction. The bank records the deposit, but note that funds in a CGAS account do not earn interest and are earmarked strictly for the purpose of reinvestment.

    • Notification:
      Once the deposit is made, you receive an account statement or certificate confirming the deposit. This document is crucial when claiming the exemption later.

    3. Procedure for Withdrawing Funds from the CGAS

    Step A: Utilize Funds for Reinvestment

    • Reinvestment:
      When you identify a new asset that qualifies for the exemption (e.g., a new residential property or eligible bonds), you must complete the purchase or construction within the prescribed time limit.

    Step B: Request Withdrawal

    • Documentation Required:
      To withdraw funds from the CGAS, you need to submit:

      • Proof of purchase or construction (such as a sale or construction agreement, payment receipts, and completion certificate)

      • The CGAS deposit certificate as evidence of the funds available.

    • Bank Process:
      The designated bank will verify the documents. Once validated, the bank will release the required amount from the CGAS to facilitate the payment for the reinvestment.

    • Excess Funds:
      Any funds in excess of what is used for reinvestment typically revert to your account; however, failure to utilize the funds within the prescribed period means that the exemption ceases, and the capital gains become taxable.

    See less
    • 0
CA Vishnu Ram
Enlightened
Asked: In:

  1. CA Sanjiv Kumar Enlightened Chartered Accountant

    The Capital Gains Account Scheme (CGAS) is a facility provided by the Income Tax Department, through its circulars and guidelines, to enable taxpayers to park the net sale proceeds (or capital gains) from the sale of a long-term capital asset when they intend to claim reinvestment exemptions under pRead more

    The Capital Gains Account Scheme (CGAS) is a facility provided by the Income Tax Department, through its circulars and guidelines, to enable taxpayers to park the net sale proceeds (or capital gains) from the sale of a long-term capital asset when they intend to claim reinvestment exemptions under provisions such as Section 54, Section 54EC, or Section 54F of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

    Purpose and Need for CGAS

    When a taxpayer sells a capital asset and is eligible for exemption by reinvesting the proceeds (or gains) in another specified asset or bonds within a defined time frame, any delay or partial reinvestment can lead to a situation where the taxpayer has not fully discharged their reinvestment obligation. To preserve the benefit of the exemption and avoid immediate taxation on the capital gains:

    • Depositing in a CGAS:
      The taxpayer can deposit the funds in a designated CGAS account with authorized banks. This deposit acts as a temporary repository for the capital gains until the taxpayer completes the reinvestment as stipulated by the applicable exemption rule.

    • Safeguard for Reinvestment:
      This mechanism allows the taxpayer to claim the benefit of exemption even if the reinvestment is completed at a later date within the prescribed time limit. It ensures that the capital gains are “earmarked” for the intended reinvestment, thereby deferring the tax liability on those gains.

    • Relevant Statutory and Guideline Context

      While the term “Capital Gains Account Scheme” does not appear verbatim in the bare act, it is an integral part of the reinvestment framework described in sections such as:

      • Section 54:
        Provides for exemption on long-term capital gains from the sale of residential house property when the net sale proceeds are reinvested in another residential property.

      • Section 54EC:
        Offers exemption on long-term capital gains if the proceeds (or gains) are invested in specified bonds (such as those issued by NHAI or REC) within six months of the sale.

      • Section 54F:
        Pertains to the sale of capital assets (other than a residential house) where full reinvestment of the net sale proceeds in a residential property is required to claim an exemption.

    See less
    • 0
CA Vishnu Ram
Enlightened
Asked: In:

  1. CA Sanjiv Kumar Enlightened Chartered Accountant

    The principal provision for claiming exemption on the capital gain from the sale of a residential house property is contained in Section 54 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 To claim exemption on long-term capital gains on the transfer of residential house property, a taxpayer must meet the following condRead more

    The principal provision for claiming exemption on the capital gain from the sale of a residential house property is contained in Section 54 of the Income Tax Act, 1961

    To claim exemption on long-term capital gains on the transfer of residential house property, a taxpayer must meet the following conditions:

    1. Nature of the Asset and Holding Period:

      • The house property being sold must qualify as a long-term capital asset. For residential house property, the asset is considered long-term if it has been held for at least 24 months (this period is applicable for properties acquired after a prescribed date, as per current law).

    2. Reinvestment Requirement:

      • Purchase Option:
        The taxpayer must invest the net sale consideration (i.e., the sale proceeds after deducting expenses directly related to the sale, such as brokerage and transfer expenses) in the purchase of a new residential house property either:

        • One year before the date of transfer or,

        • Two years after the date of transfer.

      • Construction Option:
        If the taxpayer opts for constructing a new residential house property, the construction must be completed within three years from the date of transfer of the original property.

    3. Quantum of Exemption:

      • The exemption is available only to the extent of the capital gain that is invested in the new residential property.

      • If only a part of the net sale consideration is reinvested, the exemption will be restricted proportionally; that is, only a part of the capital gain corresponding to the amount invested qualifies for exemption.

    4. Utilization and Subsequent Sale:

      • The new residential property, in which the capital gain is reinvested, must be held for the minimum period as prescribed.

      • If the new property is sold within the prescribed period (3 years for purchased property or 4 years for constructed property), the previously claimed exemption may become taxable in the year of such subsequent transfer.

    5. Documentation and Compliance:

      • Proper documentation (such as sale deed of the original property, purchase agreement or construction contract of the new property, bank statements, and relevant receipts) must be maintained as evidence to support the reinvestment claim when filing the Income Tax Return (ITR).

    See less
    • 0
CA Vishnu Ram
Enlightened
Asked: In:

  1. CA Sanjiv Kumar Enlightened Chartered Accountant

    Below is an expert-level explanation on the cases in which an Assessing Officer may refer the valuation of capital assets to a Valuation Officer under the Income Tax Act, 1961, presented in the Indian context with relevant statutory references and a clear step-by-step explanation. 1. Key Provision:Read more

    Below is an expert-level explanation on the cases in which an Assessing Officer may refer the valuation of capital assets to a Valuation Officer under the Income Tax Act, 1961, presented in the Indian context with relevant statutory references and a clear step-by-step explanation.

    1. Key Provision: Section 50C of the Income Tax Act, 1961

    The primary statutory mechanism for referring the valuation of certain capital assets is provided under Section 50C. This section specifically deals with the transfer of land or building (i.e., immovable property) and is designed to ensure that the full value of consideration for computing capital gains is not under-reported.

    Section 50C (Paraphrased):
    “Where the consideration for transfer of any land or building (or both) is less than the stamp duty value of such property as determined by a valuation officer, the stamp duty value shall be deemed to be the full value of consideration, and the assessing officer may, if necessary, refer the valuation of the property to a valuation officer.”

    2. When Can the Assessing Officer Refer the Valuation?

    The Assessing Officer has the power to refer the valuation of capital assets to a Valuation Officer in the following situation:

    A. Transfer of Immovable Property (Land or Building)

    • Situation Trigger:
      When a taxpayer transfers land or a building and the actual sale consideration declared is less than the stamp duty value as determined by a valuation officer.

    • Purpose of Referral:
      This referral ensures that the capital gains are computed on a fair value basis. The valuation officer will determine the appropriate value (usually the stamp duty value) which is then taken as the full value of consideration for capital gains computation, thereby preventing the under-reporting of the sale value.

    • Mandatory Nature:
      Under Section 50C, if the sale consideration is less than the determined value, the higher value (stamp duty value) must be adopted for the purpose of calculating capital gains. The Assessing Officer can refer to a Valuation Officer to finalize this value if the matter is in dispute or if the declared sale consideration is markedly lower than the valuation.

    3. Other Capital Assets

    • Broader Scope:
      While Section 50C specifically covers immovable property, generally for other types of capital assets (such as shares, securities, or business assets), the market value is usually determinable using market data, and no statutory referral to a Valuation Officer is provided. Hence, the referral mechanism is most commonly applicable to land and building transactions.

    4. Procedure Following Referral

    Once the Assessing Officer refers the valuation to a Valuation Officer:

    1. Valuation Process:
      The Valuation Officer examines the relevant facts, including the prevailing market conditions and stamp duty rates, to determine the fair value (often the stamp duty value) of the asset.

    2. Adoption for Capital Gain Computation:
      The value thus determined is then deemed to be the full value of consideration for computing the capital gains on the transfer.

    3. Representation by the Assessee:
      If the taxpayer disputes the valuation, they are required to file a written representation explaining the basis for a lower sale consideration. However, if the Valuation Officer’s determination stands, that value is used for taxation purposes.

    See less
    • 0
CA Vishnu Ram
Enlightened
Asked: In:

  1. CA Sanjiv Kumar Enlightened Chartered Accountant

    This section deals with the taxation of capital gains arising from Joint Development Agreements (JDA). It applies only to individuals and Hindu Undivided Families (HUFs). Bare Act Extract – Section 45(5A): "In the case of an assessee being an individual or a Hindu undivided family, the capital gainRead more

    This section deals with the taxation of capital gains arising from Joint Development Agreements (JDA). It applies only to individuals and Hindu Undivided Families (HUFs).

    Bare Act Extract – Section 45(5A):

    “In the case of an assessee being an individual or a Hindu undivided family, the capital gain arising from the transfer of a capital asset, being land or building or both, under a specified agreement shall be chargeable to income-tax as income of the previous year in which the certificate of completion for the whole or part of the project is issued by the competent authority…”

    How is Capital Gain Calculated?

    Capital gain will be calculated in the year in which the completion certificate is issued, not when the agreement is made.

    🔹 Full Value of Consideration (FVC):

    The stamp duty value (SDV) of the share of constructed property received by you + any monetary consideration received from the builder.

    🔹 Less: Indexed Cost of Acquisition (ICOA):

    The cost of the land (acquired or inherited) indexed as per Cost Inflation Index (CII).

    🔹 Capital Gain = FVC – ICOA

    Conditions to Apply Section 45(5A):

    1. Transfer is made under a registered development agreement.

    2. Applicable only to Individuals and HUFs.

    3. Completion certificate is issued by the competent authority.

    Important Notes:

    • If you sell your share in the project before completion, Section 45(5A) will not apply. In such cases, capital gain is taxed in the year of transfer under general provisions.

    • If you received advance payments, TDS @10% under Section 194-IC is applicable on monetary consideration.

    ✅ User-Friendly Example:

    Suppose you own a plot and enter into a JDA in FY 2024-25. The builder agrees to give you 3 flats + ₹20 lakhs. The completion certificate is issued in FY 2026-27. The SDV of 3 flats is ₹1.5 crore.

    Let’s assume:

    • Indexed cost of land = ₹40 lakhs

    Capital Gain = (₹1.5 crore + ₹20 lakhs) – ₹40 lakhs = ₹1.3 crore
    This ₹1.3 crore is your Long-Term Capital Gain, taxable in FY 2026-27 (AY 2027-28)

    See less
    • 0
CA Vishnu Ram
Enlightened
Asked: In:

  1. CA Sanjiv Kumar Enlightened Chartered Accountant

    ​Yes, under the Indian Income Tax Act, certain insurance claim receipts are treated as capital gains and are taxable accordingly. Here's a detailed breakdown: Taxability of Insurance Claims under Section 45(1A) Section 45(1A) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, addresses the tax implications of insurance cRead more

    ​Yes, under the Indian Income Tax Act, certain insurance claim receipts are treated as capital gains and are taxable accordingly. Here’s a detailed breakdown:

    Taxability of Insurance Claims under Section 45(1A)

    Section 45(1A) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, addresses the tax implications of insurance compensation received due to the damage or destruction of a capital asset. This section was introduced to tax such receipts as capital gains, even though there’s no actual transfer of the asset.

    ✅ Applicability Conditions:

    1. The insurance compensation is received due to the damage or destruction of a capital asset (e.g., building, machinery, land).​

    2. The cause of damage or destruction is one of the following:​

      • Natural calamities (e.g., flood, cyclone, earthquake)

      • Riot or civil disturbance​

      • Accidental fire or explosion

      • Action by an enemy or measures taken to combat such action​

    If both conditions are met, the insurance compensation is deemed as consideration received for the transfer of the asset, and capital gains tax is applicable. ​

    See less
    • 0
CA Vishnu Ram
Enlightened
Asked: In:

  1. CA Sanjiv Kumar Enlightened Chartered Accountant

    A slump sale refers to the transfer of one or more undertakings as a going concern, for a lump sum consideration, without assigning individual values to the assets and liabilities transferred. This definition is given under Section 2(42C) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. 🧮 How to Compute Capital Gains oRead more

    A slump sale refers to the transfer of one or more undertakings as a going concern, for a lump sum consideration, without assigning individual values to the assets and liabilities transferred. This definition is given under Section 2(42C) of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

    🧮 How to Compute Capital Gains on a Slump Sale (Section 50B)

    Under Section 50B, the capital gain arising from a slump sale is calculated using this formula:

    Capital Gain = Sale Consideration – Net Worth of the Undertaking

    • Sale Consideration: Total amount received or receivable for the transfer.

    • Net Worth: Treated as the cost of acquisition and improvement. It is calculated as:

      Net Worth = Aggregate Value of Total Assets – Value of Liabilities

    Important Points While Computing Net Worth:

    • Depreciable assets: Consider Written Down Value (WDV) as per Income Tax records.

    • Assets under Section 35AD: Their value is considered NIL.

    • Other assets: Taken at book value.

    • Liabilities: Taken at book value.

    • Revaluation of assets, if any, is to be ignored for this purpose.

    📅 Nature of Capital Gains

    • If the undertaking is held for more than 36 months → Long-Term Capital Gain (LTCG)

    • If held for 36 months or less → Short-Term Capital Gain (STCG)

    💡 Tax Treatment

    • Indexation benefit is not allowed under Section 50B.

    • Tax Rates:

      • LTCG: Taxed at 20% (plus surcharge & cess).

      • STCG: Taxed at applicable slab rates.

    • The gain is taxable in the year in which the slump sale takes place.

    📋 Filing Requirement

    The seller (assessee) is required to obtain a report from a Chartered Accountant certifying the computation of net worth and submit it in Form 3CEA along with the return of income.

    See less
    • 0
Load More Questions